Posts
Crisis Planning Isn't About Paranoia – It's About Staying in Business When Everyone Else Panics
The CEO looked at me across the boardroom table like I'd just suggested we hire a witch doctor. "You want us to plan for what exactly? A meteor strike?"
This was March 2019, and I was trying to convince a Melbourne manufacturing company to develop proper crisis protocols. Six months later, bushfires crippled their supply chain. Twelve months after that, COVID shut down half their operations.
That CEO? He's not CEO anymore.
Here's what 18 years of crisis consulting has taught me: the companies that survive aren't the ones with the biggest budgets or smartest strategies. They're the ones that actually think through the unthinkable before it becomes unavoidable.
The Australian Approach to Crisis Planning (Spoiler: It's Rubbish)
Let's be honest about how most Australian businesses approach crisis planning. They don't.
Oh sure, they'll have a fire evacuation plan pinned to the kitchen wall next to the roster for who brings the Tim Tams. Maybe there's a dusty OH&S folder somewhere that mentions "emergency procedures." But actual, comprehensive crisis thinking?
Most CEOs would rather discuss their colonoscopy results.
I've seen this pattern repeat itself across every industry from mining to retail. Australian business culture treats crisis planning like it treats annual leave – something you know you should do but keep putting off until it's too late. We're brilliant at adapting when crisis hits (look how we handled the pandemic), but terrible at preparing before it arrives.
The problem isn't lack of intelligence. It's cultural. We've got this deeply ingrained "she'll be right" mentality that works great for weekend BBQs but absolutely destroys businesses when genuine crises emerge.
What Actually Constitutes a Crisis Worth Planning For
This is where most crisis planning goes wrong – people either plan for everything (pointless) or nothing (fatal).
Smart crisis thinking starts with understanding the difference between disruptions and disasters. A disruption might cost you a week's revenue. A disaster threatens your entire business model.
For Australian businesses, here are the crisis categories that actually matter:
Supply chain breakdowns. Whether it's a blocked Suez Canal, a factory fire in China, or a truckie strike in WA, supply chains are fragile. I learned this the hard way when a client's entire Christmas inventory sat in containers at Port Botany during a port dispute. Six months of cash flow, gone.
Key person dependencies. What happens when your star salesperson has a heart attack? When your only IT person wins the lottery and quits? Most businesses are held together by 2-3 irreplaceable people, and losing any one of them creates immediate crisis.
Regulatory changes. New workplace laws, environmental regulations, or industry standards can emerge seemingly overnight. I've watched entire business models become illegal with a single legislative change.
Cyber incidents. Not just ransomware – though that's bad enough. What about when your payment systems go down for three days? When customer data gets breached? When your email servers crash during peak season?
Natural disasters. Living in Australia means bushfires, floods, cyclones, and droughts aren't possibilities – they're certainties. The only question is timing and impact.
The Three-Layer Crisis Thinking Model
After watching hundreds of businesses navigate crises, I've developed what I call the three-layer model. It's not about predicting the future – it's about building organisational muscle memory.
Layer One: Immediate Response Protocols
This is your "building's on fire" planning. Everyone knows what to do in the first 30 minutes, first 3 hours, first 24 hours. Who makes decisions when the boss is unreachable? How do you communicate with staff, customers, suppliers? What systems absolutely must stay running?
Most businesses stop here. Big mistake.
Layer Two: Operational Continuity Planning
This is your "how do we keep operating when normal isn't possible" planning. Alternative suppliers, remote work capabilities, temporary staffing solutions, cash flow management during revenue disruption.
The best example I've seen was a Sydney catering company that developed partnerships with three competitor caterers. When COVID hit and events disappeared overnight, they pivoted to meal delivery using their competitors' kitchens. Instead of fighting over a shrinking market, they collaborated to create a new one.
Layer Three: Strategic Adaptation Planning
This is the hardest layer because it requires imagining fundamental changes to your business environment. What if your main customer segment disappears? What if new technology makes your core service obsolete? What if supply costs triple permanently?
Layer Three thinking saved a Brisbane logistics company I worked with. When online shopping exploded during lockdowns, they quickly shifted from B2B warehouse distribution to direct-to-consumer last-mile delivery. Their competitors spent six months trying to return to "normal" while this company built an entirely new revenue stream.
Why Most Crisis Planning Fails Spectacularly
I've audited crisis plans that read like fantasy novels. Thirty-page documents outlining perfect communication cascades and detailed recovery timelines. Beautiful flow charts showing exactly how information flows up and down the organisation during emergencies.
Complete waste of paper.
Real crises don't follow your flowcharts. They're messy, unpredictable, and usually involve multiple failures happening simultaneously. The bushfires that knocked out the power that crashed the servers that encrypted the backup data that contained the customer contact database.
The crisis plans that actually work have three characteristics:
They're simple enough to remember under stress. If your crisis plan requires consulting a manual, it's already failed. Key people should know their roles instinctively.
They assume communication systems will fail. WhatsApp groups work until the cell towers go down. Email works until the servers crash. Plan for communication to break down, not work perfectly.
They're tested regularly. Not annually. Monthly. Run scenarios where key people are unavailable, systems are down, and normal solutions don't work. Make it uncomfortable. Crisis doesn't wait for convenient timing.
The best crisis test I ever witnessed was a Perth mining services company that randomly declared "crisis scenarios" during normal business hours. No warning, no preparation. Just "the main office has flooded, all computers are destroyed, and we need to service our mining contracts using only mobile phones and backup staff."
Brutal? Yes. Effective? Absolutely.
The Psychology of Crisis Thinking
Here's something they don't teach in business school: crisis planning isn't really about logistics. It's about psychology.
When genuine crisis hits, rational thinking becomes a luxury. People revert to habits, emotions take over, and logical decision-making gets replaced by panic responses. Unless you've trained different responses.
I've noticed something interesting about leaders who handle crises well. They're not necessarily the smartest or most experienced. They're the ones who have mentally rehearsed crisis scenarios enough times that their responses become automatic.
Workplace abuse training often covers this psychological aspect – how stress affects decision-making and why preparation matters more than intelligence during emergencies.
Think about airline pilots. They don't handle emergencies well because they're brilliant under pressure. They handle emergencies well because they've practiced emergency procedures thousands of times in simulators. Their crisis responses are muscle memory, not improvisation.
Your business needs the same approach.
The Technology Trap
Every second business I consult thinks technology will solve their crisis planning challenges. "We'll use cloud backup!" "We'll implement disaster recovery systems!" "We'll get better cybersecurity!"
Technology helps. But it also creates new vulnerabilities.
I worked with a Brisbane accounting firm that invested heavily in cloud-based everything. Completely automated backups, redundant systems, military-grade security. Then their internet provider had a major outage that lasted four days. All that cloud technology became completely useless because they couldn't access it.
Technology amplifies good planning. But it can't replace human thinking and preparation.
The most resilient businesses I've worked with use technology as a tool, not a crutch. They maintain offline capabilities, alternative communication methods, and manual processes that can function when digital systems fail.
Building Antifragile Operations
Nassim Taleb talks about antifragility – systems that don't just survive stress but actually improve because of it. This concept revolutionised how I think about business crisis planning.
Instead of just protecting against downside risks, smart businesses build operations that can benefit from unexpected changes. The restaurant that can quickly switch between dine-in, takeaway, and catering depending on circumstances. The consultancy that can seamlessly move between face-to-face workshops and online training.
Antifragile businesses don't just bounce back from crises. They emerge stronger.
A perfect example is how some retailers handled supply chain disruptions by developing relationships with local suppliers. Initially more expensive, but when international shipping became unreliable, these local relationships became competitive advantages.
The key is building optionality into your operations before you need it.
Common Crisis Thinking Mistakes
Mistake #1: Planning for the last crisis.
Just because bushfires hit your area last year doesn't mean bushfires are your biggest risk this year. Crisis planning should focus on impact patterns, not specific events.
Mistake #2: Assuming rational behaviour.
Your carefully crafted communication plan falls apart when stressed employees stop checking email, customers panic-buy everything in sight, and suppliers prioritise their biggest clients over their most loyal ones.
Mistake #3: Overlooking cascade effects.
The initial crisis is rarely what kills businesses. It's the secondary and tertiary effects. The supply shortage that forces price increases that triggers customer departures that creates cash flow problems that prevents loan repayments.
Mistake #4: Underestimating recovery time.
Most businesses plan for crises lasting days or weeks. Modern crises often last months or years. COVID wasn't a three-week disruption – it permanently changed how business operates.
The Mindset Shift That Changes Everything
The biggest breakthrough in crisis thinking isn't tactical – it's philosophical.
Stop thinking about preventing crises. Start thinking about dancing with them.
Crises will happen. Supply chains will break. Key people will leave. Technology will fail. Economic conditions will shift. Regulations will change.
The question isn't whether these things will happen. The question is whether your business can adapt quickly enough when they do.
This mindset shift changes how you structure everything. Instead of rigid processes, you build flexible systems. Instead of single-point dependencies, you create redundancy. Instead of perfect plans, you develop rapid response capabilities.
Practical Crisis Thinking Exercises
Here's how to start building genuine crisis thinking into your business:
The "What if?" sessions. Monthly meetings where you explore specific scenarios. Not to create detailed response plans, but to identify assumptions, dependencies, and vulnerabilities. What if our main supplier disappeared tomorrow? What if our lease wasn't renewed? What if our biggest customer went bankrupt?
The dependency audit. Map out everything your business depends on to function. People, systems, suppliers, customers, locations, regulations. Then ask: what happens if each one disappears?
The communication drill. Practice communicating with your team using only backup methods. No email, no Slack, no office phones. How quickly can you reach everyone? How do you coordinate responses?
The worst-case scenario. Once a quarter, spend an hour imagining the worst possible combination of problems hitting simultaneously. Not to create paranoia, but to stress-test your thinking and identify preparation gaps.
Leadership skills development becomes crucial during these exercises because crisis response often reveals leadership gaps that weren't obvious during normal operations.
When Crisis Thinking Goes Too Far
There's a line between prudent planning and paralysing paranoia. I've worked with business owners who became so focused on potential crises that they stopped taking any risks at all.
The goal isn't to eliminate all vulnerabilities – that's impossible and counterproductive. The goal is to build adaptive capacity.
Some business risks are worth taking because the potential upside justifies the exposure. Smart crisis thinking helps you distinguish between acceptable risks and existential threats.
The Crisis Communication Reality
Most crisis communication plans assume clear information, rational audiences, and functioning systems. Real crisis communication is messier.
Information is usually incomplete, contradictory, and changing rapidly. Audiences are stressed, emotional, and often not listening carefully. Communication systems are overloaded, unreliable, or completely down.
The businesses that communicate well during crises aren't the ones with the most sophisticated systems. They're the ones that practice communicating under difficult conditions.
They've pre-written template messages for common scenarios. They've identified backup communication channels. They've trained multiple people to speak for the company. They've established relationships with local media before they need them.
Most importantly, they've learned to communicate uncertainty honestly rather than pretending to have answers they don't have.
The Future of Crisis Thinking
The nature of business crises is changing faster than our ability to plan for them.
Climate change is making weather-related disruptions more frequent and severe. Global connectivity means local problems can become international crises within hours. Automation creates new dependencies while eliminating old redundancies.
The businesses that thrive won't be the ones that predict these changes perfectly. They'll be the ones that build adaptive capacity into their operations from the ground up.
Crisis thinking is becoming a core business competency, not an optional extra. Companies that treat it as compliance exercise will struggle. Companies that embed it into their culture and operations will dominate their industries.
Related Resources:
Our Favourite Blogs: